Best Ice Cream Makers for Overall

Analyzing reviews from 33 Sites…

15 out of 19 products found

Sort By

Overall Homemade Ice Cream Kids Overall Soft Serve Sorbet More ▼

Capacity Clean Up Durability Freezer Frozen Yogurt Gelato Ice Cream Density Sherbet Speed Storage Vanilla

For Overall, people talk about

clean up
speed
ice cream variety
delicious

Price (Go)

Brand: Select

Features: Select

Cuisinart ICE-30BC 2 Quart

$63.00 Est. at Amazon

from Joan, www.cooking.com
This product makes delicious ice cream, plus it's so easy to use and to clean. Every household should own one..I recommended it highly.
from www.cooking.com
I have used this ice cream maker every week since I got it. I make ice cream for my husband each week and diet sorbet for my self each week. I love the way I can make a diet product for my self and
from www.buydig.com
Summary: For a family that enjoys their ice cream this product offers a fun way to experiment together and enjoy the results. You can change recipes to decrease or even eliminate fat. You can add
from www.cooking.com
Although I gave this product as a gift. I know that the people that received it are extremely happy with the Cuisinart Ice Cream maker.
from Janine, www.cooking.com
Lots of fun. Easy to use. Am still playing with the recipes but enjoy the product. Do allow plenty of time for the liner to freeze and time for the ice cream to finish in the freezer if you want

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Works Fast, Good Durability, Max Bowl Capacity: 2 Quart

2 RECOMMENDED by 21 people for OVERALL

Lello 5030

$1,150.00 Est. at Amazon

from Vickie, www.cooking.com
This is an amazing product. I will admit I was somewhat skeptical and I thought the price to be way to high but the end result is fantastic. I highly recomend this product. As much ice cream as
from Gary, www.cooking.com
Great quality. The first ice cream maker I've had that makes great ice cream simply. Easy to clean. The only drawback is that it is not small nor light weight, but definetly a quality product.
from Marjorie, www.cooking.com
This is a wonderful product and it really works well. Everything about it is excellent and the only drawbacks are obvious: it is expensive and takes up a lot of space but if this is no problem, it is
from Rebecca, www.cooking.com
WOW! WHAT A GREAT ICE CREAM MAKER! IT IS QUITE PRICEY BUT THE OLD ADAGE
from Herbert, www.cooking.com
My granddaughter and I love homemade ice cream, both making it and eating it. She is not as much of a

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Good Durability, Works Fast, Max Bowl Capacity: 2 Quart

3 RECOMMENDED by 46 people for OVERALL

Hamilton Beach 68220 1.5 Quart

$36.00 Est. at Amazon

from Marion, www.cooking.com
I found the product easy to use and was making ice cream in no time. I did try to substitiute a couple of things as I wanted a low fat version of ice cream and it came out ok but needs more work
from Nicki, www.cooking.com
This ice cream machine is fantastic! It is a little small but with just my husband and I it is perfect. It does take a little longer to make the ice cream than the instruction booklet says, and the
from Jeffrey, www.cooking.com
I followed the advice of others who own this product and focused on making sure everything was COLD COLD COLD. And you know what? It works great - I have zero complaints. The frozen insert does
from Margaret, www.cooking.com
This product is excellent. Works well, is relatively quiet, & was an excellent price. I would recommend this to anyone looking for an ice cream maker.
from JoAnna, www.cooking.com
Have made several batches of ice cream after receiving my Ice Cream maker!!.. I LOVE it!!!.. Got alot of my ice cream recipes off of the Internet.. So easy to use & clean up is a breeze!!!.. No more

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Works Fast, Large Capacity, Max Bowl Capacity: 1.5 Quart

4 RECOMMENDED by 13 people for OVERALL

Whynter IC-2L 2 Quart

$265.00 Est. at Amazon

from Miche "Michele T", www.target.com
This is a powerful little unit, that has the same output as larger more bulky units. The mixing speed is great and the compressor freezing bowl is a fantastic upgrade to those self freeze styly ice
from www.amazon.com
After reading other reviews, it was decided to purchase this Whynter Ice Cream Maker. Four batches of Ice Cream later, this was definetly the right choice. Very simple to use and absolutely GREAT
from www.amazon.com
Surprisingly good quality ice cream from this little device. I've made all kinds of crazy flavors with this. My flavor of the month is Chocaloate Peppermint Schnapps (I tweak this ingredient
from www.amazon.com
The quality of the ice cream is surprisingly good. The texture is almost professional or retail quality. I'm impressed.
from www.amazon.com
Look at the reviews of the Lello Gelato Pro 4090, Whynter makes them for Lello under a private label. Its a great Machine.

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Excellent Durability, Works Fast, Max Bowl Capacity: 2 Quart

5 RECOMMENDED by 90 people for OVERALL

Cuisinart ICE-50BC 1.5 Quart

$265.00 Est. at Amazon

from www.cooking.com
No more ice and salt! I'll be making much more ice cream because it's so easy with this product!
from Gib, www.cooking.com
Had product for two weeks. Works well. makes an adequate amount of ice cream for a family of four. Easy to setup. Need to taker beater out as soon as done to prevent it freezing into the container
from www.cooking.com
Fantastic product. Makes great ice cream and sorbet.My only complaint is that the motor on this is really, really loud. Best suited to be put into another room while it's working. Besides that,
from By Dan, reviews.homedepot.com
The product is of high quality and is easy to operate. I've used itabout six times to make ice cream and the results have been delicious and refreshing each time. The machine is a little on the noisy
from "Dave", www.abt.com
Works great...A little noisy Wish it made larger batches...1.5 qt... overall,very happy with product!

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Works Fast, Excellent Durability, Max Bowl Capacity: 1.5 Quart

Hamilton Beach 68330 4 Quart

$36.00 Est. at Amazon

from "Samanthas2", www.chefscorner.com
this product works great, easy to use and easy clean up. i bought it as a gift for my husband.
from "Homemade Ice Cream Girl", www.chefscorner.com
The lid is white. When preparing vanilla ice cream it is difficult to see when it is beginning to reach the top. On the one I had previously, the lid was clear.
from www.absolutehome.com
this product works great, easy to use and easy clean up. i bought it as a gift for my husband. Pros: Easy to Use, Quick Best Uses: Custom Flavors Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
from www.amazon.com
THis product is AMAZING! I researched and researched ice cream makers and found this lovely item. Being so cheap- and a 4qt (much larger than the others!) I was a bit leery... Low and behold it
from www.amazon.com
As other reviewers have pointed out the product is loud, but it works. I last used it on the Fourth of July and got rave reviews for the ice cream. Just follow the directions in the enclosed

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Works Fast, Large Capacity, Max Bowl Capacity: 4 Quart

Industrial Revolution f-icep

$27.00 Est. at Amazon

from www.amazon.com
I love this product. My daughter (12 years) received it for Christmas. She made ice cream Christmas Day and the next day with her friends. The ice cream is a little runny at first, but we just put
from www.amazon.com
This is a great product for the family. Lots of fun to roll around and make ice cream. It is sturdy. Don't bother with the pint sized on though. You need the quart size or you get very little to enjoy
from www.amazon.com
Great product. Play with the ball and make ice cream at the same time. It's fun and it works!
from www.amazon.com
I love this product especially in large group setting so everyone can take a turn rolling it. It takes about 30-45 min. to make ice cream so the more people to help the better. The kids love it!
from www.amazon.com
This is a great product for kids, they really enjoyed the short period of time it took to make ice cream!

There are so many ice cream recipes out there that can all be used with this.

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Works Fast, Good Durability, Single Speed

Deni 5200

$44.00 Est. at Amazon

from Lisa, www.cooking.com
I have made several batches of ice cream with this handy little ice cream maker. My husband loves it. He screams for ice cream daily. Good job Deni.
from Christian, www.cooking.com
I've wanted a ice cream maker for months now. When I saw a great deal for this one I wanted to scream. No pun intended lol. this produt works a miracle and has help to create great family time in
from www.amazon.com
Have had it for a little over a week. Have made ice cream 3 times. It is great. Very easy to use and clean up is fast and easy too. Haven't had it long enough to know if it will stand the test of
from www.amazon.com
I received this as a present, originally had an issue with the freezer canister, and called Customer service and they immediately sent out an replacement. Since it was only a part that needed to
from craftyginny, www.shopping.com
Pros: Is very easy to clean and takes up minimal space. Cons: Would like it to be a little larger.

Read more reviews

Positives: Good Durability, Easy To Clean, Works Fast, Single Speed

Deni 5201 1.5 Quart

$51.00 Est. at Amazon

from Richard, www.cooking.com
The product works well with the following exceptions:1. The top is not easy to secure in place2. The tub is not large enough for the receipe as the ice cream over flows and makes a mess when you let
from betty, www.cooking.com
. Ours is 2 years old. We have greatly enjoyed it.
from www.amazon.com
I received this as a present, originally had an issue with the freezer canister, and called Customer service and they immediately sent out an replacement. Since it was only a part that needed to
from www.amazon.com
Have had it for a little over a week. Have made ice cream 3 times. It is great. Very easy to use and clean up is fast and easy too. Haven't had it long enough to know if it will stand the test of
from www.amazon.com
I bought the Deni ice cream maker with candy crusher (Model 5210) to replace my older Deni Ice Cream Factory machine. I've made ice cream now three times in this new one, and all three times the

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Great Durability, Works Fast, Max Bowl Capacity: 1.5 Quart

Rival 8706M 6 Quart

$40.00 Est. at Amazon

from www.shopping.com

Pros: When it worked it made good ice cream quickly

Cons: the problem I am now having makes it difficult to get good ice cream.
from www.shopping.com
Pros: Makes lots of ice cream in less than 2 hours total.
Cons: Machine is large, and loud.
from www.amazon.com
THE RIVAL ICE CREAM FREEZER IS GREAT FOR MAKING HOME MADE ICE CREAM. IT IS LIGHT-WEIGHT, BUT VERY DURABLE AND EASY TO CLEAN. I AM VERY HAPPY WITH THE PURCHASE.
from www.amazon.com
It was a good value for the price. Easy to operate. Ice cream did not freeze to thick enough consistancy after several hours, so we put it in the freezer to solidfy it even more. Other than that
from www.amazon.com
the icecream maker performed as i expected it to, a great choice for the price, my first batch was a lavender sorbet, and it came out great. you can't go wrong here.

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Excellent Durability, Works Fast, Max Bowl Capacity: 6 Quart

Rival 8806 6 Quart

$44.00 Est. at Amazon

from A Customer from Amarillo, TX, clickfrom.buy.com
I am very pleased with my new ice cream freezer. The ice cream is delicious! The sales and delivery were very prompt. I would recommend buy.com to my friends and co-workers.
from www.amazon.com
This product worked very good. Ice cream was frozen to where it was hard to get the paddle out. Kudos to Rival.
from www.amazon.com
Bought this product for home and camping; am very happy with it. Ice cream is ready very fast and is quite good. Bought the Ben & Jerry's book for a variety.
from www.amazon.com
I've been making home made ice cream for years and this product works great. The smaller, more compact ice bucket is more efficient and less bulky than the larger wood models. The end product is
from www.amazon.com
I've really enjoyed this product. I was worried when I first purchased it over a year ago that it might a little too cheap quality-wise but figured since the price was cheap too, it was worth the

Read more reviews

Positives: Works Fast, Easy To Clean, Excellent Durability, Max Bowl Capacity: 6 Quart

Deni 5205 1.5 Quart

$52.00 Est. at Amazon

from www.amazon.com
I received this as a present, originally had an issue with the freezer canister, and called Customer service and they immediately sent out an replacement. Since it was only a part that needed to
from www.amazon.com
Have had it for a little over a week. Have made ice cream 3 times. It is great. Very easy to use and clean up is fast and easy too. Haven't had it long enough to know if it will stand the test of
from www.amazon.com
I bought the Deni ice cream maker with candy crusher (Model 5210) to replace my older Deni Ice Cream Factory machine. I've made ice cream now three times in this new one, and all three times the
from www.amazon.com
I have recently purchased this product about a week ago and have made 3 successful ice cream recipes so far. The first thing I noticed when turning on the machine is that it is rather noisy,
from www.amazon.com
I've made ice cream with this machine four times and it has been delicious every time with every recipe that I have tried. I made a mistake the first time I used it (I don't count that time), I

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Nice Durability, Works Fast, Max Bowl Capacity: 1.5 Quart

Cuisinart ICE-45 1.5 Quart

$94.00 Est. at Amazon

from naomi, www.cooking.com
I used this for a barbecue ove r the 4th of July and it was a big hit. The best recipe was the coffee ice cream. Chocolate on was not that good. I will try some of the other recipes I have for ice
from www.amazon.com
This is an excellent product.
Once the bowl is chilled, the ice cream is made ina very
short time. The mix-ins are a little messy but it is a lot
of fun and the ice cream tastes
from www.amazon.com
Excellent product for the money. It worked as advertised and I use it on a regulary basis. My ice cream comes out perfectly each time. The only drawback is the need to freeze the bowl before each
from www.amazon.com
I have really enjoyed this product... The grandkids think it's even better!
John
from www.amazon.com
We love the way the ice cream is despenced, just like at the ice cream soft serve shop. Being able to instantly add yummy extras made this great product even better.

Read more reviews

Positives: Works Fast, Easy To Clean, Great Durability, Max Bowl Capacity: 1.5 Quart

VillaWare 5100 1 Quart

$50.00 Est. at Amazon

from www.overstock.com
This product is awesome! My husband and I both love using it and I don't even really like ice cream, so this is a way to change it up! Perfect for anyone!
from www.ekitchengadgets.com
This is a great product. I keep the freezer bowl in the freezer all the time so it's always ready. What could be easier. Throw a few things together start machine before dinner and thats it you have
from www.ekitchengadgets.com
Should I not be satisfied with this product can I return it? Thanx
from www.overstock.com
This is an easy to use machine, no ice, no rock salt. Ice cream is fairly soft but you can place in freezer if want it harder. Make sure ingredients are cold before adding or may not freeze well.

Read more reviews

Positives: Works Fast, Large Capacity, Max Bowl Capacity: 1 Quart, Multiple Speed

Back to Basics ICMDIS 1.5 Quart

$32.00 Est. at Amazon

from "Fsmith", www.everycoffeemaker.com
I bought this for my 7 year old step-daughter's birthday. She loves it. An adult must supervise the machine, but it's very easy to use. Comes with suggested recipes for ice creams, etc. I've
from "fsmith", www.everycoffeemaker.com
I bought this for my 7 year old step-daughter's birthday, but the entire family loves it. Simple recipes included with the machine, done in 30 minutes. Seems to be fool-proof. It is slightly loud,
from www.amazon.com
Makes excellent sorbet and ice cream; and VERY easy to use. Great price and very easy to use, without the cranking of the old fashioned ice cream machines. Children will enjoy using this product as
from www.amazon.com
Have had it for a little over a week. Have made ice cream 3 times. It is great. Very easy to use and clean up is fast and easy too. Haven't had it long enough to know if it will stand the test of
from hutchie, www.shopping.com
Pros: red colour Cons: weak blade, loud, poor quality The Bottom Line: Poor quality, flimsy scraping blade and the bucket fell apart.

Read more reviews

Positives: Easy To Clean, Works Fast, Max Bowl Capacity: 1.5 Quart, Multiple Speed

Rival 8804-BL

$28.00 Est. at Amazon

from Gamma2natenate, www.target.com
Bought it today and tried some ice cream this afternoon, delicious, just delicious. Xcellant value, works great
from www.target.com
My husband and I purchased this machine about a month ago and it works great! As long as the directions are followed correctly (as is true with most anything!)the ice cream will come out beautifully!
from Shay L. Scofield, www.target.com
I have never made ice cream before and decided to get an ice cream maker. I purchased this one by Rival and I also purchased the Ben & Jerry's Homemade Ice Cream & Desert Book. I came home and made
from Christopher Morley, www.target.com
This is the lowest priced "Old Fashion" (Rock Salt and Crushed Ice) Ice Cream Maker on the market. It has a powerful motor. And the new oval design makes storage easier. Salt water is naturally hard
from Northwoods Camper, www.target.com
I have used mine dozens of times. Always get good reviews, the kids love it. Great for RV fun.

Read more reviews

Positives: Excellent Durability, Works Fast, Max Bowl Capacity: 4 Quart

Sassafras 22217

$24.00 Est. at Amazon

from Neva, www.cooking.com
This product was bought as a Christmas gift for a little girl whose name we chose off of the Angel Tree at Walmart in Prattville, Alabama. That was sponsored by the local Salvation Army. We hope
from Roy & Andrea, www.cooking.com
This is a good ice cream maker for children. It is easy to use and the ice cream is good. I just wish there were more recipes to use.
from Estrella, www.cooking.com
I bought this for my daughter's 7th birthday. She loves ice cream and she loves to cook. I was surprised how good the ice cream actually was. It makes a nice amount, enough for my family of 4.
from Sharel, www.cooking.com
Great value and easy to use.
from Christie, www.cooking.com
We were very disappointed with our ice cream maker purchase. The item kept damaging our batteries so that they kept needing to be replaced throughout the one and only time we tried to use it. The ice

Read more reviews

Positives: Works Fast, Single Speed

Rival GC9155

$39.00 Est. at Amazon

from www.amazon.com
This machine is easy to use, easy to put together, and easy directions to follow. It does exactly as advertised. I would recommend this to anyone who wants homemade ice cream at home and doesn't
from kbolton72, www.shopping.com
Pros: Your own recipes, turns out great Cons: You have to make several batches in 1/2 hour intervals The Bottom Line: If you are tired of spending big money on Ben & Jerry's and want to
from www.amazon.com
I got this machine a couple days ago hoping to make ice cream. After following the instructions carefully and chilling the canister for 24 hours, I plugged it in, and 40 minutes later I had a few
from www.amazon.com
Even after following the directions, chilling the gel canister for 48 hours, and chilling my mixture to the required temperature, this machine couldn't freeze anything! I bought it as a back-up to
from www.amazon.com
When I first got this I followed the directions on the box for chocolate cookie ice cream exactly (which specified refrigerating the mixture for 30 minutes and freezing the gel canisters for 24

Read more reviews

Positives: Great Durability, Max Bowl Capacity: 1.5 Quart

Aroma AIC-304EM

$50.00 Est. at Amazon

from www.amazon.com
This is a great product, and you can get it, along with any other products on Amazon up to $500 Free! Participate in a special promotion and get a free $500 Amazon Gift Card at this web site:
from www.target.com
We bought this ice cream maker and have used it twice so far. First time everything went smoothly...until the very end, the motor just stops and the ice cream isn't even finished. We checked it out
from www.target.com
I was hoping to save a little money and ordered this ice cream maker instead of one that's twice the price. I mixed my ingredients, which was just Half and Half, sugar, and vanilla and poured it in
from www.ekitchengadgets.com
from www.target.com
When I saw this product, the first thing I thought of was when my father used to ask us kids to sit on the hand cranker while he cranked. I bought it for the nostalgia, but the quality is there too.

Read more reviews

Positives: Nice Durability, Max Bowl Capacity: 5 Quart, Bowl Amount: Single

Also Try:

More ▼

Home and Garden

Ice Cream Makers

Best Ice Cream Makers for Overall

Cuisinart ICE-30BC 2 Quart

Lello 5030

Hamilton Beach 68220 1.5 Quart

Whynter IC-2L 2 Quart

Cuisinart ICE-50BC 1.5 Quart

Hamilton Beach 68330 4 Quart

Industrial Revolution f-icep

Deni 5200

Deni 5201 1.5 Quart

Rival 8706M 6 Quart

Rival 8806 6 Quart

Deni 5205 1.5 Quart

Cuisinart ICE-45 1.5 Quart

VillaWare 5100 1 Quart

Back to Basics ICMDIS 1.5 Quart

Rival 8804-BL

Sassafras 22217

Rival GC9155

Aroma AIC-304EM

6 Quart

All

Children

Yoghurt

Me

Top Brands

More Brands

Max Bowl Capacity

Speeds