I just bought another Brother 4 in 1. I love them. Works well, pen replacements are reasonable, prints out photos beautifully, color is good, scans, faxes, copies and prints. Here are some suggestions to check out.

Actually, I think you can get away with spending far les than $200+. The one I use and absolutely love is the Brother MFC-440CN. It's an all-in-one that has built in networking, which is great for today's connected homes. The only drawback to it is that it is an inkjet printer, but the ink carts are separate and relatively cheap -- about $11 each.

It's a lot of printer for the price, and Brother has always made some rather nice, long-lasting products. In fact, this is my 3rd Brother printer! I have two laser printers and now this one and they all have exceeded my expectations.